Stop Paralysing Yourself: Why Indecision is Killing Your Career (And Your Soul)

Our Favourite Blogs:

• SpaceTeam Blog - Essential workplace insights
• Learning Sphere Posts - Professional development gold

Look, I'm going to be brutally honest here. After eighteen years of watching people tie themselves in knots over the simplest bloody decisions, I've had enough. Yesterday, I watched a senior manager spend forty-five minutes deliberating whether to order chicken or salmon at our quarterly lunch. Forty-five minutes! While the rest of us sat there wondering if we'd picked the wrong table.

But here's the thing that gets me fired up - this same bloke can't make strategic decisions for his team either. Last month, his department missed a crucial deadline because he spent three weeks "evaluating options" for a software upgrade that any first-year business student could have chosen in an afternoon.

The Real Cost of Your Hesitation

You know what really grinds my gears? People who think being indecisive makes them thorough. Wrong. Dead wrong. It makes you ineffective, and frankly, a bit of a liability.

I learned this the hard way back in 2009 when I was managing a team in Brisbane. We had a client crisis - nothing major, just needed to choose between two perfectly acceptable solutions. I spent a week going back and forth, seeking input from everyone from the cleaner to the CEO's mother-in-law (okay, slight exaggeration). By the time I finally made a call, our client had found another supplier. Lost a $200K contract because I couldn't pick between Option A and Option B.

That failure taught me something crucial: in business, a quick good decision beats a perfect slow one every single time.

Why Your Brain Sabotages You

Here's where it gets interesting. Our brains are actually wired to make us terrible decision-makers in modern workplace environments. Back when our ancestors were deciding whether that rustling bush contained berries or a sabre-toothed tiger, taking time to weigh options made sense. Getting it wrong meant becoming lunch.

But these days? The worst that happens if you choose the wrong project management software is you spend a few months learning a different interface. Yet we still activate that same ancient circuitry that treats every choice like life or death.

Dr. Barry Schwartz calls this the "paradox of choice" - basically, the more options we have, the more paralysed we become. And mate, has he got that right. I've seen teams spend months evaluating fifteen different solutions when any of the top three would have done the job perfectly well.

The emotional intelligence factor plays a huge role here too. When we're emotionally invested in being "right," we often end up being chronically slow instead.

The Aussie Approach to Decision Making

You want to know what I love about working with tradies? They make decisions. Fast. Good ones too, most of the time. A sparkie doesn't stand around for three hours debating which wire to connect first - they assess, decide, and get on with it. If it doesn't work, they fix it and move on.

Compare that to the corporate world where we've somehow convinced ourselves that every decision needs a committee, a risk assessment, and probably a focus group. Bollocks.

I remember working with a construction company in Perth where the site foreman made more good decisions before 9 AM than most executives make in a week. He didn't have the luxury of endless deliberation - materials needed ordering, crews needed directing, and deadlines weren't optional.

The 80% Rule That Changed Everything

Here's something that'll revolutionise how you work: the 80% rule. If you have 80% of the information you need and 80% confidence in your decision, make it. Right now. Today.

Why? Because that extra 20% will either never come or won't significantly change the outcome anyway. And while you're sitting around waiting for perfect clarity, your competitors are out there implementing their 80% solutions and gaining ground.

I started applying this rule religiously about five years ago. My team's productivity shot up by roughly 40% (and yes, I'm making up that statistic, but it felt massive). More importantly, we stopped missing opportunities because we were stuck in analysis paralysis.

When Perfectionism Becomes Procrastination

Let me tell you about Sarah (not her real name, obviously). Brilliant analyst, fantastic at her job, completely crippled by her need to have all the answers before making any decision. She'd research every angle, create beautiful spreadsheets, and present options that were so thoroughly analysed they'd make a university professor weep with joy.

But she never actually decided anything.

Her reports would conclude with phrases like "further investigation required" or "additional data would be beneficial." Classic perfectionist procrastination masquerading as thoroughness.

The irony? When I finally pushed her to make quick decisions with incomplete information, her success rate was about the same as her heavily researched ones. Sometimes time management means accepting "good enough" and moving forward.

The Questions That Cut Through The Noise

When you're stuck in decision limbo, try these three questions:

What's the worst realistic outcome? Not the catastrophic nightmare scenario your brain loves to conjure up, but the actual worst thing that could reasonably happen. Usually, it's not that bad.

What happens if I do nothing? This is the hidden cost most people ignore. Indecision is still a decision - you're choosing to maintain the status quo. Is that really what you want?

Can this be undone or adjusted later? Most business decisions aren't permanent. You can change software, restructure teams, or pivot strategies. Very few choices are truly irreversible.

I use these questions daily, and they've saved me countless hours of pointless deliberation.

Learning From the Wrong Choices

Here's an unpopular opinion: making the occasional wrong decision is good for you. It builds what researchers call "decisional confidence" - basically, your ability to trust your judgement and course-correct when needed.

I've made some absolute howlers over the years. Hired the wrong person (twice), invested in a training program that was complete rubbish, and once chose a conference venue that was so remote it might as well have been on Mars. But each mistake taught me something valuable about my decision-making process.

The people who never make wrong decisions? They're not making enough decisions.

The Leadership Test

If you're in any kind of leadership role, your indecisiveness doesn't just affect you - it cascades down through your entire team. Nothing kills morale faster than a manager who can't make a call.

I've watched talented people leave good companies because their boss couldn't decide on basic operational issues. When your team doesn't know whether the project is going ahead, whether the budget's approved, or what the priorities are, they start looking for environments where someone actually makes decisions.

Your people need direction, not endless consultation sessions that go nowhere.

Stop Overthinking, Start Deciding

Look, I'm not saying you should make reckless choices or ignore important information. But somewhere along the way, many of us forgot that decision-making is a skill that improves with practice, not something you perfect through theoretical analysis.

Start small if you need to. Choose your lunch quickly. Pick a route home without checking three different traffic apps. Buy the first decent shirt you see instead of visiting eight stores.

Then work up to bigger decisions with the same mindset: gather enough information, trust your judgement, and move forward.

Your career, your team, and your sanity will thank you for it. Because at the end of the day, the only thing worse than making the wrong decision is making no decision at all.

And if you're still reading this instead of deciding on something you've been putting off, well... you know what you need to do.

Make the call. Today.